PENR3L – A PASCAL European Network Helping Social Capital Development
Jucevicienne P, Longworth N and Osborne M.J.
Background and Rationale
Propelled by the forces of globalisation, rapid change and the need for social inclusion, national, regional and local governments are transforming their view of education. The imperative to increase social, intellectual and human capital in order to survive in an increasingly dynamic and complex employment and community environment now drives the development agenda. The aim is not just to provide learning, lifelong, for all citizens of a city, region and nation, but to actively create the culture of learning that will encourage and enable them to participate in it continuously. Education is no longer the preserve of the education department, it pervades every sphere of local and regional government and affects the way that governance is organised and managed.
This challenges the traditional way in which local and regional authorities are administered. Changing cultures is a huge task. It entails more participation, more contribution from stakeholders, more bottom-up, informed decision-making, more local, national and global vision, more understanding, more wisdom, more knowledge and insight, to mention just a few. The management of place becomes more urgent.
Hence the terms ‘Learning City’, ‘Learning Town’, ‘Learning Region’ and ‘Learning Community’ are rapidly becoming commonplace in debate at all levels of government. More than 50 cities and regions in the United Kingdom now describe themselves under that label, as do cities in other countries of Europe, such as Gothenburg, Rotterdam, Dublin, Brno, Limerick and Livorno, to name but a few. Espoo leads an informal Finnish network of some 20 ‘learning municipalities.’ It is also catching on in the rest of the world. China has requested its 61 largest cities to develop learning city plans, and all cities and towns in Victoria (Australia) have become learning cities and towns. This is the beginning of a large and rapidly growing movement to respond to modern day needs.
In some universities too, there has been an awakening of awareness of the potential of the learning cities/regions movement to stimulate action in this field, and to provide the research, development, information and assistance that communities and cities need in order to implement the right policies and strategies in local government.
Such a partnership between town and gown can be extremely fruitful, but it is all too rare. The major objective of PENR3L, therefore, is to enlarge the PASCAL European network of cities, regions and university expertise centres that can work together to provide solutions and knowledge, keep local and regional authorities informed and make contact with similar initiatives elsewhere in the world.
PEN - A European network for PASCAL
In order to give the development of PASCAL in Europe a push forward, Stirling University and its partners in the LILARA (Learning in Local and Regional Authorities) project made a successful proposal (PENR3L) to the European Commission. Its rationale is that the development of learning cities and regions will not happen unless there is a viable network of expertise centres, normally based in one or more universities in each European country, working with practitioners from local and regional government to carry out the necessary research and to push forward the learning cities and regions agenda. In this it mirrors the PASCAL world-wide objectives.
PENR3L’s objective is therefore to establish a dynamic and growing working network of expertise centres and forward-looking local and regional authorities that will work together to accelerate the growth throughout Europe of learning cities and regions, ready to meet the challenges of the 21st century. It will do this by organising:
- Two lively seminar/workshops– in Barcelona, Spain and Kaunas (Lithuania) for academics and practitioners from each country of Europe. Here they will discuss the state of the art, identify needs for the future and establish a sustainable network to ensure that local and regional government can stay tuned to the changing vicissitudes of learning city/region development
- A major conference in Limerick (Ireland) that presents the results of these seminar/workshops to a wider audience, and launches the network to a larger membership. This too will focus on best practise and on practical synergies between the two types of participant.
Each of these events will have a certain number of free and subsidised places, and we will be inviting interest from potential participants early in 2007.
PASCAL
PASCAL originated from OECD. It is a much-needed growing network of local authorities and universities to address the needs of local and regional authorities in matters of place management, social capital and learning regions. Its European hub operates from the University of Stirling and comprises universities from several European countries together with regional authorities such as Kent and national authorities dealing with local government issues, such as the Scottish Executive. It has equally knowledgeable partners in the state of Victoria, Australia, where most cities and towns are now learning communities, and is aiming to spread into other parts of the world. Its goal is to provide the knowledge and the tools that enable local and regional authorities to become dynamic learning communities, cities and regions, building up their social, Intellectual and human capital to meet the demands of the 21st century. Already its partners have produced ‘Stakeholder Audits’, tools to stimulate local authorities and their stakeholders in universities, small businesses, adult colleges and schools to become ‘learning organisations’, working together to construct learning cities. Its LILARA (Learning in Local and Regional Authorities) Project is currently auditing local authorities to discover the learning needs of local government employees vis-a-vis their role in the same process, and there are web-based learning materials to assist in this. ’Hot Topic’ papers, written by expert practitioners present the cutting edge. Conferences such as this one in Pecs, offer an opportunity to bring together experts and practitioners from all sides in productive debate.
The PENR3L target audience
There are 4 main target groups for the seminars and conference, and for the ensuing network:
- Managers and administrators in local and regional authorities who take responsibility for implementing lifelong learning city and region actions.
- Leaders and researchers in expertise centres in universities and other establishments with a wish to contribute more in the field of learning cities and regions.
- Decision-makers in adult education establishments, business and industry, teacher training, schools and other stakeholder establishments in the locality.
- City, Regional and community leaders including elected representatives who make the decisions to develop strategies and policies for learning city and regional development.
All of them are stakeholders in the construction and maintenance of Learning Cities and Regions.
What’s in it for local and regional government ?
The extent to which a city and its people learn will be a measure of their ability to meet the challenges of the 21st century in terms of prosperity, stability and the well-being of its citizens. That basic concept is emphasised in almost every report produced in the past 20 years. Many cities and towns do already aspire to improve the provision of learning and have installed new learning centres and publicity machines to encourage people to use them. Most local authority websites have a section devoted to lifelong learning. But few have understood that a learning city/region is one which involves everyone in the process of continuing personal development, contribution and decision-making, much in the same way that a learning organisation constantly involves its employees in quality improvement and decision-making at the appropriate point. Provision, support and exhortation are not enough. Learning Mindsets and methods also need to change.
Placing learning at the forefront of a city’s or region’s strategies and policies can engender a qualitative progression, but it entails much more than adjusting educational opportunities. Learning should pervade every aspect of local and regional government practice using the lifelong learning tools and techniques that help to stimulate people to develop their own potential to the full. There are tools and techniques to help with this, individual personal and professional continuing development programmes to put in place and learning materials to insert into these.
Based on the premise that every employee in local administration should, for example have a personal stake in the development of the authority as a learning entity, as should other stakeholders, the LILARA project, also the focus of a round table at the PASCAL Pecs conference, has already identified a huge reservoir of learning need in the six authorities with which it is working. Multiplied across the European continent, the demand is limitless. The European Commission’s policy paper on the local and regional dimension of lifelong learning puts it thus ‘‘No city or region can afford not to be a learning city or learning region if it wishes to develop future prosperity, maintain social stability and realise the potential of its citizens.’ (2). Local and regional government will need all the help it can get from PENR3L and PASCAL.
PENR3L so far
The project is
- building up a database of key local and regional authority people and organisations through contact with its own partners and with other sources, including the web
- developing publicity materials outlining the content and methodology of the workshops and distribute these to interested people
- organising the workshops in Kaunas (Lithuania) on December 6/7 and Barcelona, on 25/26 October 2007. Normally 2 delegates from each country of Europe, one academic and the other a practitioner, are attending one or other of the workshops
- Organising the conference for Limerick in May 2008. Open to everybody, this will pull together all themes from the workshops and establish the PASCAL European Network.
The partners?
There are 7 partners in PENR3L, each of them liaising with their own local and regional authorities and establishing databases within a European region
- University of Stirling, Scotland (Coordinator) dealing with UK, Benelux,
- University of Catania, dealing with Italy, Greece,
- University of Limerick, Ireland, dealing with Ireland and Germany
- Ecole Superieure de Commerce, Toulouse, dealing with France, Spain and Portugal
- Akershus University College, Drammen, Norway, dealing with the Nordic countries
- University of Pecs, Hungary dealing with Romania, Bulgaria, the Balkans and Slovakia
- University of Kaunas, dealing with the Baltic States, Poland and the Czech Republic
Workshops content
As we all know the scope of new activities within learning cities and regions is wide. The following gives an indication of the topics that will be open for discussion
Theme 1: Learning Regions, Learning Cities and Economic Development
Sub themes
1. Characteristics of Learning Regions and Cities
- What constitutes a learning region – how is it different
- Research, knowledge, intelligence and information
- Sustainability
2. Learning Organisations in a Learning Region
- Characteristics of Learning Organisations
- Continuous learning development and support programmes for whom? Why? what? how?
- Conditions for developing Innovation and creativity
- Stakeholders as Learning Organisations- Stakeholder audits
3. Stakeholders and their roles
- Who are the stakeholders
- Stakeholder Capital in learning cities and regions
- Partnerships and purposes – local, national, European, Global
4. Marketing and publicising Learning Cities and Regions
- Methods and media of communication
- Communicating internally – to organisations and people
- Marketing the learning region to the wider world
5. Resources and Capital
- Building capital and resource
- Profiting from capital and resource
6. Employability, Employment, skills and learning etc
- Lilara – discovering and satisfying learning needs in local authorities and stakeholders
- Learning Needs – content, methods and sources of materials
- Skills for 21st century learning cities and regions
- Management Tools and techniques– plp’s, audits, mentors, guides etc
Theme 2: Learning Regions, Learning Cities - Social and Community Development
Subthemes
1. Creating a culture of learning – why? how? – breaking down barriers.
- Stakeholders and their roles – especially voluntary and community organisations
- Tools and techniques in a social setting, plps, personal audits, mentors and guides
- Coping with Diversity, multi and inter-culturalism
- Learning Needs, content, methods and providers
2. Consultation, involvement and democracy
- Consultation methods – from information to empowerment
- Neighbourhood strategies
- Improving involvement and democracy
3. Active Citizenship and volunteering
- mobilising people and communities
- volunteering strategies
- Networking citizens of all ages
4. Environment, climate change and sustainable development
5. Continuous learning/development and support programmes
6. Resources and Capital - as above concentrating on social capital
Theme 3: Learning Regions, Learning Cities – Networking, intelligence and knowledge
Sub themes
Needs and requirements of cities and regions
What intelligence and how to communicate
What partnerships?
What resources for the network
Politics and structures
Practical steps
Network Communication methods
Network Sustainability
These comprise an eclectic and comprehensive set of sub-themes. However, they are not complete. Each delegate to the workshops will bring his/her own knowledge, experiences, expertise and ideas and will be encouraged to articulate these.
Organisation of Workshops
The workshops open with a keynote presentation that raises the issues to be discussed and summarises some of the initiatives, insights, tools and learning materials that have informed the learning city and learning region movement in the previous 8 years.
In addition. the three themes above will give rise to a keynote which outlines the state of the art in that theme and gives examples of good practice.
However, by attending the workshops, it is intended that everyone will be both teacher and learner. The formal presentations are kept to a minimum, and active solution sessions in which smaller groups discuss, and create an action agenda for, specific aspects of learning city/region practice will predominate Delegates will share ideas, experiences, knowledge and their hopes and needs for the future in an atmosphere of productive dialogue. This will be no talk shop. Some exercises to stimulate mental energy and creative thought will be used. The objective of establishing a working European Network, with links to global expertise and practice that can continue to provide a dynamic forum for all for years to come, will be met.
Further Information?
Useful References
PASCAL International conference ‘ Lifelong Learning in the City-Region, September 23-25 2007, please see website
www.pascal2007conf.pte.hu
Commission of the European Union, (2001) ‘The Local and Regional Dimension of Lifelong Learning, creating learning cities, towns and regions,’ European Policy paper’(N Longworth, author), DG Education and Culture, Brussels
Duke C, Doyle, LE and Wilson B (eds) (2005), ‘Making Knowledge Work – Sustaining learning communities and regions’. NIACE UK
Duke C, Osborne M and Wilson B eds (2005), Rebalancing the Social and Economic – Learning Partnerships and Place’ NIACE UK
Longworth N (2006), ‘Learning Cities, Learning Regions – Lifelong Learning and Local Government’ (Taylor and Francis) available through
www.longlearn.org.uk/book4.html/